Same name, different person: how to tell your ancestor apart
In many Polish villages, a few surnames were shared by half the parish, and first names like Jan, Józef, Maria or Marianna were everywhere. This is the most common reason online family trees go wrong. Here is how to avoid it.
Why mix-ups happen so often
Imagine two men called Jan Kowalski, both born around 1820 in the same parish. One is your ancestor, the other is a cousin or a stranger. If you take the first baptism you find, you may follow the wrong family for generations. Many trees online are built like this, and the mistake is copied again and again.
Check more than the name
A link between two generations is only safe when several details agree. Compare:
- the parents’ names, including the mother’s maiden name;
- the age given at marriage and at death, and whether it fits the birth year;
- the village and house number, where they are written down;
- the spouse named in later records;
- godparents and witnesses, who were often relatives.
A marriage record usually helps the most, because it names both sets of parents. A death record often gives the spouse and the age, which helps confirm you have the right person.
Look at everyone with the same name
Before deciding which baptism is your ancestor’s, list every person with the same name born in the parish in those years. Then follow each of them a little: did one die as a child? Did one marry in another village? Often only one person fits all the facts.
Be honest when it is not clear
Sometimes the records simply do not decide it. Then the right thing is to say so, write both options down, and look for another source, such as a neighbouring parish, a gravestone or a later document. A good family history marks a guess as a guess.
This is also why, when we find someone who may or may not belong to your family, we ask you before we continue. That way strangers do not end up in your tree, and you decide where the research goes.
More guides
- How to find your Polish ancestors
- How to find the Polish village your ancestors came from
- Polish church records
- Polish ancestors from Galicia
- How to read a Polish parish record from 1868–1917 (central Poland)
- Silesian ancestors in Texas
- Free word list for old Polish parish records (PDF)
- Finding your ancestors from the Kielce region
- Your grandfather served with the Polish Forces
- Research example: one woman, several surnames
- How to hire a Polish genealogist: what to check first
- Polish genealogy research: prices and what’s included
- All guides
When it’s worth asking for help
Many people manage the first steps on their own. It gets hard when:
- you don’t know the name of the village the family came from,
- the record is handwritten in Russian or Latin,
- the books for your parish are not online,
- two families in the parish had the same names.
If one of these sounds familiar, start with a free check. Tell me what you know about one family line or one parish. Usually within 3 working days I’ll reply whether and where the parish books for that place are recorded as surviving, according to archive catalogues and online inventories, and which package fits your search. This is a free initial check of catalogues and availability, not the search itself. You pay only if you decide to go ahead with a package.
Ask for a free checkSee packages and prices